PurpLE Project

This project focuses on researching the tension between public procurement and private law.

Project title

Purchase Power – Sustainable Public Procurement through private Law Enforcement PurpLE

Funding

carlsberg foundation

Semper Ardens: Accelerate Grant KR. 4.991.514

Project period

Sep. 1, 2022 – 31 Aug. 2025

9

Research Question 1

How does public procurement law impact the interpretation of contract law?

9

Research Question 2

Can private law limit the outcome of public procurement law and, if so, how?

9

Research Question 3

What does this complex interaction between public procurement and private law mean for achieving the United Nations Sustainable Development Goals agenda?

About the Project

The Purchase Power – Sustainable Public Procurement through Private Law Enforcement (PurpLE) Project explores the connection between public procurement law and commercial contract law within Europe. These two areas of law interact differently depending on how each country chooses to regulate them.

In general, there are two main approaches, often referred to as the “public” and “private” models.

  • In the public model, administrative law plays the leading role, while commercial contract law steps in only where public law doesn’t cover certain aspects of the contract.
  • In the private model, public contracts are treated more like private ones, and commercial contract law takes centre stage.

Whenever commercial contract law applies to public contracts, interesting questions arise. For example, does the law apply directly, or does it need to be modified to suit the specific nature of public contracts? One area where this is particularly interesting is already during the formation of public contracts, such as dealing with issues of “culpa in contrahendo” (which means pre-contractual liability).

The PurpLE Project predominantly but not exclusively focuses on the performance of public contracts and looks at topics like:

  • How commercial contract law applies to public contracts.
  • The responsibilities of public buyers when contracts need to be changed.
  • Risk-sharing between parties and how public contracts can be terminated.
  • The recent case law of the European Court of Justice (ECJ) on contract modifications.
  • How concepts like “diligent authority” impact public contract performance.
  • The conditions under which a public contract can be changed due to unforeseen hardships.

The project also explores sustainable and innovative procurement practices, focusing on:

  • Innovation: How computational contracts (smart contracts) are being used in public procurement.
  • Sustainability: How due diligence clauses are enforced in public and private contracts, and whether third parties can enforce sustainability clauses.

Additionally, the project looks into the role of arbitration in public contract disputes, investigating whether arbitration can be used effectively in both the public and private models of public procurement.

The PurpLE Project brings together experts in public procurement and commercial contract law from several EU countries, making it a unique initiative. The findings will be valuable for both academia and legal professionals.

The project’s results are shared through seminars, conferences, academic publications, open-access blogs, and podcast episodes on the BEstek Public Procurement Podcast. In addition, a collaborative anthology will be published as open access by the end of 2025.

Deliverables

Published and submitted peer-reviewed articles in journals:

Monographs and contributions to books

  • O. Hansen, M.Andhov & T. Tanggaard Jacobsen, “Bygherrens opgivelse af rettigheder i udbudspligtige kontrakter – ændringer under bagatelgrænsen i udbudslovens § 180” in C.Risvig Hammer, M.Andhov et al. Into the Northern Light – in memory of Steen Treumer (2022 Ex Tuto Publishing). Available here.

Other communication in public media

Presentations held at symposiums, conferences etc.

  • M. Kania presentation on Hardship clause in the performance of public procurement contracts from the perspective of the Coronavirus pandemic and war in Ukraine during the “Public procurement in times of crisis: national experiences” conference organised by the Public Procurement Law Research Group at the University of Tartu, School of Law on 26 January 2023. Read more about it here.
  • M. Andhov Chaired a panel on Contract Modifications in Public Procurement at the Conference Into the northern light – In memory of Steen Treumer on 2.12.2022. Read more about it here. 
  • M.Andhov & M. Kania – Panel organisation and presentation PERFORMING PUBLIC CONTRACTS PANEL – the Opaque Interplay Between Public Procurement and National Contract Law in collaboration with in partnership with ADVOKATFIRMAN VINGE law firm, made a contribution at the NordicPublicProcurementForum 2023. Read more about it here. 
  • M. Andhov & M. Kania – Panel organisation titled “A Question of Trust and Cooperation” at the 2024 Global Revolution Conference at the University of Nottingham. They presented research on “The Doctrine of Culpa in Contrahendo in Public Procurement.” Read more about it here.

Research Stays

  • M. Kania presentation on Hardship clause in the performance of public procurement contracts from the perspective of the Coronavirus pandemic and war in Ukraine during the “Public procurement in times of crisis: national experiences” conference organised by the Public Procurement Law Research Group at the University of Tartu, School of Law on 26 January 2023. Read more about it here.
  • M. Andhov Chaired a panel on Contract Modifications in Public Procurement at the Conference Into the northern light – In memory of Steen Treumer on 2.12.2022. Read more about it here. 
  • M.Andhov & M. Kania – Panel organisation and presentation PERFORMING PUBLIC CONTRACTS PANEL – the Opaque Interplay Between Public Procurement and National Contract Law in collaboration with in partnership with ADVOKATFIRMAN VINGE law firm, made a contribution at the NordicPublicProcurementForum 2023. Read more about it here. 
  • M. Andhov & M. Kania – Panel organisation titled “A Question of Trust and Cooperation” at the 2024 Global Revolution Conference at the University of Nottingham. They presented research on “The Doctrine of Culpa in Contrahendo in Public Procurement.” Read more about it here.

Researchers

Marta Andhov

Associate Professor

Marta Andhov

Marta Andhov, PurpLE’s principal investigator, is an Associate Professor at Faculty of Law, the University of Copenhagen. Her main research interests focus on public procurement law, sustainability, governmental contracts and interaction between public and private law in international trade. You can read her full bio on the Bestek website here.

Michał Kania

Senior Researcher

Michał Kania

Michał Kania is a Senior Researcher at the PurpLE project at the Centre for Private Governance at the University of Copenhagen, Faculty of Law. His research efforts in PurpLE project are directed towards dealing with the questions regarding public procurement law’s impact on the interpretation of contract law. His main research expertise focus is public procurement law, Public-Private Partnerships, and concession contracts.  Before taking a position at the University of Copenhagen, Michał was a professor at the University of Silesia in Katowice, Faculty of Law.

Sven Mikulic

Research Assistant

Sven Mikulic

Sven Mikulic is a student research assistant at the University of Copenhagen, Faculty of Law, and is currently pursuing an MSc degree in International Business and Politics at Copenhagen Business School. Aside from his involvement in the PurpLE project, he is also actively contributing to SAPIENS and COCOREADO research with a focus on the economic analysis of sustainable public procurement law and policies. Additionally, he is also investigating contract automation systems and other LegalTech topics from a business perspective within Copenhagen Legal Tech Lab.